Welcome to Elsie's Plate & Pie
Elsie's Plate & Pie, located at 3145 Government St in Baton Rouge, LA, is redefining comfort food with its creative Cajun twists. Patrons rave about dishes like the Natchitoches Three Meat Pie and flavorful seafood bisque, celebrated for their richness and depth. This hidden gem combines stellar service with a warm atmosphere, making it a must-visit for food lovers. Guests highlight standout items like boudin cakes and lemon icebox pie, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to quality and flavor. With surprisingly affordable pricing, Elsie’s offers an exceptional culinary experience, making it a top contender in Baton Rouge's dining scene.
Elsie's Plate & Pie: Reviews & Ratings
Stellar service, refreshingly creative and outstandingly delicious. I got the perfect mix of savory and sweet with a Natchitoches Three Meat Pie and Apple pie. Our server Leigh was wonderful! Even my picky friend ended up ordering two entrees and a dessert!! The pricing is surprisingly low for such a unique, well crafted menu and experience. 100% coming back!!
Overly delicious! I know that Elsie’s is newer to Baton Rouge , but this has to be in the top 3 for best spots in town. I had the meat pie - the seafood bisque - and the red beans and rice. This rendition of classic Cajun is the best I have seen and tasted. The meat pies were overflowing with flavor. The red beans and rice - easily the best I’ve ever had. The seafood bisque was just impeccable. It was rated the best spot in Baton Rouge cause it is the best in Baton Rouge. Such a treasure to the community.
Great food. Got the boudin cakes, meat pie, and lemon ice box pie and it was excellent. Service was really good. We had a wait but its due to their great food so its understandable
Very excellent food! Had the crab fingers app, deep fried, but fresh. The seafood pie was excellent! Bubbly hot, Burnt my mouth because I couldn't stop eating!! Only critique, sauce needs to be spicier! Good, but could be better! Side salad fresh. Service was good! Atmosphere, busy at lunch time!! Parking lot ful!! Note - from the main road, the place looks closed, closed down! I did see a "parking in the back" sign and luckily I did. Great find!!
This place is a hidden gem! We liked it so much we went back a second time. Seafood Pie is delicious, fried chicken with red beans and rice is amazing! The fried okra app was pretty tasty and the pimento cheese dip drizzled in honey, I've been thinking about it since we left Baton Rouge!
Experienced this awesome place while on vacation and I highly recommend! Had the seafood pot pie and red beans and rice. Amazingly delicious! Friend had the hot crawfish melt! Very tasty! Then dessert was blueberry pie with lemon glaze! So good! Excellent service too! Nice clean restaurant with great vibe!
Everything was amazing. Super delicious food, good portion sizes. Had one of the best pastry stouts I've ever had in my life. 10/10 would highly recommend. The turtle pecan pie was divine, too.
All I can say is wow! Hidden gem? Maybe. But when you have a 30-minute wait, I'd say it isn't hidden. Rum don't walk to this restaurant. Service was fantastic. Very nice and super attentive. Food is spectacular. Grilled pimento cheese sandwich? A Shrimp poboy? A fresh shrimp fried perfectly falling out... I literally can't wait to go back. If you are in the Baton Rouge area... you HAVE to stop in.
Location
-
3145 Government St, Baton Rouge, LA 70806, United States Hotline: +1 225-636-5157
Welcome to Elsie's Plate & Pie, a delightful culinary treasure nestled in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. Located at 3145 Government St, this charming eatery is quickly becoming a standout destination for food lovers with its refreshingly creative approach to classic Cajun and Southern cuisine. With a focus on outstanding flavors and a unique menu, Elsie's has earned rave reviews from patrons eagerly returning for more.
As you step inside, you're greeted not just by the tantalizing aroma of freshly prepared dishes, but also by the warmth of attentive service. Diners have praised the staff, highlighting the exceptional service provided by servers like Leigh, who enhance the dining experience with their friendly demeanor and keen recommendations. This welcoming atmosphere pairs perfectly with the restaurant's commitment to quality, making every visit feel special.
Let's talk food—oh, the food! Guests have been captivated by the Natchitoches Three Meat Pie, bursting with savory flavors that promise indulgence in every bite. For those with a sweet tooth, the Apple Pie has become a celebrated staple. From boudin cakes to perfectly crafted seafood bisque and red beans and rice, each dish reflects a dedication to authentic Louisiana flavors. Customer reviews underscore this sentiment, with one diner noting that it was the best rendition of classic Cajun cuisine they had ever tasted. The meat pies are renowned for being overflowing with flavor, while the fried chicken paired with red beans and rice has respondents coming back for seconds.
It's evident that Elsie's Plate & Pie is not just another restaurant; it stands out as a culinary gem, offering hearty dishes at surprisingly affordable prices. As Thomas Williams aptly put it, the seafood pie was so irresistible that he couldn't stop eating it—an endorsement few restaurants could claim. Add in delightful appetizers like fried okra and the unique pimento cheese dip drizzled in honey, and you find yourself making a mental list of all the must-try items.
Despite being relatively new to Baton Rouge, Elsie's has quickly carved out a reputable presence among local food joints. Customers often describe it as a hidden gem, demonstrating that the word is spreading about this vibrant spot. Whether you're a lifelong resident or just passing through, Elsie's Plate & Pie is a dining experience that’s not to be missed. Come for the food, stay for the ambiance, and leave with a satisfied palate and a smile on your face.
For inquiries or to make a reservation, you can contact them at +1 225-636-5157. Every dish at Elsie's Plate & Pie tells a story of flavor, creativity, and a passion for food that truly feels like home.